Public Opinion on Vouchers as SB 3 Gets a Committee Hearing in the Senate

The February 2017 University of Texas/Texas Tribune Poll asked battery of questions about public education policy that included two items related to vouchers that provide context for the March 21 Senate Education Committee hearings on SB 3, the omnibus voucher/school schoice bill sponsoered by Senator Larry Taylor.  The bill, which is the vehicle for Lt. Governor Patrick's efforts to introduce more private options into the k-12 education system, includes a form of educational savings accounts as well as scholarship set asides that parents can use for private school options.  Below are some key results on the questions we asked, followed by brief comments Josh Blank and I wrote about the results shortly after the poll was released.

Loading chart...
categorycolumn-1
Support35%
Oppose44%
Don't know21%

Loading chart...
categoryDemocratIndependentRepublican
Support25%24%46%
Oppose55%57%33%
Don't know21%18%21%

Loading chart...
categoryDemocratRepublicanTea Party
Support25%44%63%
Oppose59%38%22%
Don't know16%19%15%

Loading chart...
categoryUrbanSuburbanRural
Support39%32%34%
Oppose40%48%42%
Don't know20%20%24%

The poll asked people to rate the effectiveness of various proposals, including vouchers, in improving public education.

Loading chart...
categorycolumn-1
Extremely effective20%
Somewhat effective26%
Not very effective16%
Not at all effective19%
Don't know19%

Loading chart...
categoryDemocratIndependentRepublican
Extremely effective10%14%29%
Somewhat effective22%24%32%
Not very effective16%19%13%
Not at all effective35%23%6%
Don't know17%22%20%

Loading chart...
categoryLiberalsModeratesConservatives
Extremely effective12%10%32%
Somewhat effective13%24%33%
Not very effective16%21%11%
Not at all effective46%19%6%
Don't know13%25%17%

Loading chart...
categoryDemocratRepublicanTea Party
Extremely effective10%22%48%
Somewhat effective21%32%32%
Not very effective16%17%7%
Not at all effective37%6%3%
Don't know17%23%10%

The poll also asked respondents to choose the most effective among the ideas they rated.

Loading chart...
categorycolumn-1
Creating a school voucher program13%
Expanding the number of charter schools7%
Increasing the pay of public school teachers13%
Increasing funding for the public school system20%
Providing more incentives for individuals to choose teaching as a profession8%
Reducing the number of standardized tests students must take21%
Increasing opportunities for online learning4%
Grading individual schools on an A-F scale7%
Expanding state-funded, pre-kindergarten programs7%

Loading chart...
category18-2930-4445-6465+
Creating a school voucher program7%9%13%22%
Expanding the number of charter schools9%7%5%8%
Increasing the pay of public school teachers15%9%16%12%
Increasing funding for the public school system22%25%19%15%
Providing more incentives for individuals to choose teaching as a profession4%10%7%12%
Reducing the number of standardized tests students must take24%24%19%14%
Increasing opportunities for online learning6%3%5%3%
Grading individual schools on an A-F scale7%6%7%8%
Expanding state-funded, pre-kindergarten programs7%8%7%6%

Loading chart...
categoryDemocratRepublicanTea Party
Creating a school voucher program2%11%40%
Expanding the number of charter schools2%11%13%
Increasing the pay of public school teachers18%13%3%
Increasing funding for the public school system30%20%1%
Providing more incentives for individuals to choose teaching as a profession11%6%3%
Reducing the number of standardized tests students must take17%21%23%
Increasing opportunities for online learning5%4%2%
Grading individual schools on an A-F scale3%10%12%
Expanding state-funded, pre-kindergarten programs11%5%2%

From shortly after the poll was released.

2. Vouchers by any other name are still a hard sell in Texas.  The results from our education battery provide useful context for the current tensions in the Texas legislature over school vouchers, choice, scholarships, etc.  School vouchers, called exactly that, are tied with reducing the number of tests as the measures seen as most effective by Republicans.  Yet the share of Republicans that think increasing spending, either in the system overall or targeted to teachers, actually slightly exceeds the share that favors vouchers.  It's not surprising that a Senate prioritizing a voucher-by-another-name approach and a House searching for ways to re-approach school funding seem at loggerheads. There is a constituency for each in their party. The two items that probe opinions on vouchers reveal an interesting facet of Republican responses to subject. When we use the term voucher in the context of the potential for improving public education in Texas, Republicans embrace the idea by a wide margin (61%-19%), amidst the predictable level of Democratic opposition (32%-51%).  But when we ask about the underlying policy of voucher or voucher-like programs -- redirecting state tax revenue to parents to pay for private or parochial schools --  Republican support drops (46%-33%) amidst even deeper Democratic opposition, and other cleavages (like the urban-rural divide) are more activated.  The results suggest that the determination among voucher advocates to purge the use of the word "voucher" is aimed more at gaining non-Republican support.  They also illustrate the rationale for legislatively tortuous efforts to build a policy that attempts to redirect dollars destined for the state before they are actually taken in as public funds.